Electric Breast Pump vs Manual: Which One Is Better?
According to the U.S. Breastfeeding Committee, nearly 84.1% of infants are put on exclusive breastfeeding. However, as the child grows, mothers tend to prefer formula over breastfeeding, possibly because of going back to work for long hours. However, as moms are becoming more conscious of how important breast milk is for their child, using a breast pump to collect and store it has become the norm. In this regard, both manual and electric breast pumps have been introduced in the market over the past few years.
Breastfeeding nurtures the bond between a mother and her child
In this article, we will dive into the difference between manual and electric breast pumps in terms of their advantages and limitations. In addition, some of the well-known breast pump brands have also been linked for the reader’s convenience.
What are Breast Pumps?
Breast pumps are the medical tools primarily used by moms to pump milk. This way, they can increase their milk supply, manage the plugging of milk ducts, as well as treat engorged breasts. Being regulated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), breast pumps are reliable devices that are durable as well as highly affordable.
What are Electric Breast Pumps?
As the name suggests, electric breast pumps operate either through a battery or a power outlet that charges the system. Unlike manual breast pumps, which are for single breast expressing, these electric breast pumps can be employed for a single or double breast expression.
To use these devices, the breast shield or cup is placed over the nipples, and the connected milk collection cup is there to receive the pumped milk. As soon as the pump is turned on, a suction is created that initiates pumping.
Despite the fact that the working mechanism of both the manual and the electric breast pumps is the same, the difference lies in convenience as the later allow mothers to use only one hand for operating the device while the manual ones need to be handled by both hands.
Advantages
Like manual systems, electric breast pumps also provide several advantages, some of which have been summarized as follows:
Rapid Operation
Electric breast pumps are known for their quick action and fast pumping that saves a lot of time to moms, especially while pumping at workplaces. Usually, most electric breast pumps can be operated for a 30-minute cycle.
Greater Suction Power
Another important factor while using a breast pump is the extent of suction it can provide. In case of electric breast pumps, hospital-grade suction can be achieved to make the pumping process faster. In addition, these devices also come with multiple suction strength options that allow mothers to choose the most suitable settings depending on their personal preference.
Increase in Milk Supply
In addition to their use for pumping, electric breast pumps are also employed by moms to increase their milk supply especially at the start of their breastfeeding journey. This is because the stimulation phase of an electric breast pump massages the breast tissue to prepare it for milk expression. This way, lower milk supply can be enhanced.
High Convenience and Efficacy
Apart from the above-mentioned benefits, electric breast pumps are also convenient to use and are highly efficient in their performance. As they allow one-hand operation, mothers can multitask while pumping.
Limitations
Despite providing several benefits, electric breast pumps also have certain limitations:
Power Dependency
Electric breast pumps use electric power to operate. After 3 hours of usage that often includes 3 to 8 pumping cycles, an electric breast pumps needs to be recharged. This way, the use of the system gets hindered when the device is on charge.
Bulkier Systems
Because of having more components as compared to manual breast pumps, these electric systems become bulkier and heavier in weight. This feature makes them less portable as well.
Heavy on the Budget
As electric breast pumps have more components, they are pricier than manual pumping devices. Therefore, the users have to pay a higher amount to get a product that might also need maintenance in terms of parts replacement over the years.
What are Manual Breast Pumps?
Manual breast pumps are the most budget-friendly option in their domain
Manual breast pumps are one of the most widely used pumping systems that do not require a battery or a power source to operate. These come with a squeezable handle that creates the vacuum necessary to express milk. To use the device, the breast shield is connected to the nipple. An empty milk collection container is also attached to the assembly.
Once the handle or lever is pumped, the suction force comes into play, and milk starts coming out of the milk ducts. Most mothers prefer manual breast pumps over electric ones because of their affordability.
Advantages
The following are some of the pros of manual breast pumps that render them the first choice of most mothers:
Ease of Usage
Manual breast pumps are easy to use owing to their simple construction. As they do not use a battery or a power source, there are no wires that are to be connected. You just simply have to put the breast shield on and start pumping.
Lightweight and Portable
Manual breast pumps are lighter in weight than the electric breast pumps. This way, they can be easily carried around to pump on the go.
Budget-Friendly Product
Another advantage of manual breast pumps is that these are cheaper and, therefore, more budget-friendly than electric breast pumps. This is simply because a manual breast pump consists of fewer parts which do not require a battery or a power source. As a result, the overall product cost remains less.
Unhindered Usage
One of the biggest advantages of manual breast pumps is that they can be used without any hindrance at any time of the day as well as at night. This is because, unlike electric breast pumps, which require recharging after almost 3 hours of usage, manual breast pumps are simply operated by squeezing the handle manually.
Limitations
Despite being budget-friendly and easy to use, manual breast pumps also come with some of the following limitations:
Requirement of Greater Strength
Using a manual breast pump can be tiring for mothers as it requires hand strength. During a pumping cycle of 20 to 30 minutes, you have to keep squeezing the handle continuously to maintain the milk expression.
Slower Pumping
As compared to the electric breast pumps, the manual ones are slower and take more time to pump the same amount of milk that can be expressed by electric pumps within a few minutes.
One Side at a Time
Generally, manual breast pumps can be used on one breast at a time, which makes the pumping process longer.
Manual vs Electric Breast Pumps: What is Better?
When it comes to choosing between a manual and an electric breast pump, always keep in mind that both devices have their own pros and cons. None of these can be declared as superior to the other. The choice, however, lies on the user’s personal preferences, the duration and frequency of intended usage, the need to carry the device while being outdoors, as well as on the budget.
Electric Breast Pump
Breast Pumps at Health Supply 770: Features and Specifications
Breast pumps are medical devices designed to ease the process of pumping for lactating mothers. These are available in different kinds, including wearable, manual, and electric breast pumps. All of these systems have their own pros and cons.
When it comes to learning about the difference between manual and electric breast pumps, it is also essential to look into some of the products that many brands manufacture. Some of these well-known brands are also available at Health Supply 770 and have been detailed below, along with their features and purchase links:
Double Electric Breast Pump Zomee Z2 ZOMEE Z2 12/CS
Double Electric Breast Pump Zomee Z2 ZOMEE Z2 12/CS
Product Details
Double electric Zomee Z2 breast pumps are a product of Zev Supplies Corporation, China. Being constructed using food-grade plastic that is free from BPA and phthalates, the product is soft and safe for use among mothers with a sensitive skin type.
These Double electric Zomee Z2 breast pumps have a few components that are easy to assemble. Once put together, the product creates a leak-proof seal that allows pumping with minimal risk of leakage. Moreover, these Double electric Zomee Z2 breast pumps can automatically switch between the stimulation and expression modes.
Luna AAA0013 Double Electric Breast Pump Kit EACH
Luna AAA0013 Double Electric Breast Pump Kit EACH
Product Details
Luna AAA0013 double electric breast pump kits come with a lightweight product (weigh only 2 pounds) that is ideal for use among mothers who are working women or are handling numerous outdoor tasks that necessitate pumping on the go. Another factor that increases the portability of these systems is their compact and discreet size.
Moreover, these Luna AAA0013 double electric breast pump kits have a mechanism of preventing contamination of the tube and the motor by restricting the backflow of pumped milk. This way, the product does not require a lot of maintenance on a frequent basis.
Additionally, these Luna AAA0013 double electric breast pump kits do not produce a loud noise that is often common with using a breast pump. In this regard, the noise level never crosses 43 decibels. Furthermore, the device can also mimic your baby’s natural sucking pattern.
Drive Medical RTLBP1000 Pure Expressions Single Channel Electric Breast Pump
Drive Medical RTLBP1000 Pure Expressions Single Channel Electric Breast Pump
US$104.99
Product Details
Drive Medical RTLBP1000 Pure Expressions single-channel electric breast pumps work by understanding and then copying the natural sucking pattern of your child. When attached to one breast at a time, the device initiates its stimulation phase that massages the breast tissues so that pumping can be easier. Then the device shifts to the expression phase, in which milk is sucked. This way, the product helps collect milk at a faster rate while keeping moms comfortable.
Moreover, these Drive Medical RTLBP1000 Pure Expressions single-channel electric breast pumps come with 9 different suction strengths that allow mothers to choose an option according to their suitability. In addition, a 30-minute timer can be set for each pumping cycle. Once settings are done for one cycle, the device keeps a memory of these features.
In addition, these Drive Medical RTLBP1000 Pure Expressions single-channel electric breast pumps are smaller in size and are, therefore, portable as well. As for their construction, these products are manufactured using silicone that is flexible and free from allergens and toxins such as latex, BPA, etc.
*Note: The prices of these items mentioned in the article are taken from the Health Supply 770 website. These may vary over time.
Pumping also increases the milk supply especially in new moms
The products mentioned in this article, while learning about the difference between manual and electric breast pumps, along with many other medical supplies, can be purchased from Health Supply 770, a reliable name when it comes to medical products. They have a 30-day money-back guarantee and provide your products to you in the shortest possible time. Click the link at the end of the article to check the wide range of respiratory products.
Conclusion
Breast pumps are medical devices that have been designed to not only to pump milk but also to increase its expression, especially in new moms. Moreover, these devices also find applications in the treatment of engorged breasts that cause pain and swelling.
When it comes to choosing between a manual and electric breast pumps, keep in mind that both devices have their own advantages as well as limitations. For instance, if the electric breast pumps are more rapid and efficient, they are more costly as well. On the contrary, manual breast pumps take more time but fit in most people’s budgets. Therefore, the choice narrows down to the mother’s personal preferences.
Considering their importance, breast pumps should be kept in healthcare facilities as well as in home settings to use whenever necessary. For purchasing different types of breast pumps, reliable vendors like Health Supply 770 should be approached. They ensure the provision of quality products along with satisfactory services.
References
